AI in Marketing. The reality.

The year of “AI will fix it all”

If you work in marketing, you’ll know the last year or two have been somewhat interesting to say the least…

AI swept in like a shiny new toy. You know, the one your 4-year-old thinks is the bee’s knees and everyone wants it.

With that came businesses seeing it as a way to cut costs, churn out content quickly and do more with less. For freelancers and agencies (like us here at Conv3rt), it felt like the rug had been pulled from under us. 

Budgets shrank and briefs vanished. We saw too many companies swapping out human creativity for an algorithm. 

And spoiler alert… it hasn’t gone well.

The hype vs the reality 

The truth is though that marketing does not live in a vacuum. I’m going to say that again…

Marketing does not live in a vacuum.

It lives in human connection, cultural nuance and emotional resonance. AI is great at generating words, but AI cannot build trust, understand humour, shared lived experience, or be a great storyteller. 

Theory backs this up. (This isn’t just me sat her slagging AI off – the research shows this).

Gartner’s Hype Cycle:

If you haven’t heard of Gartner’s Hype Cycle before, it’s a good’un. It’s a visual representation of the ways in which we adopt and implement new technologies through five distinct phases.

  1. The technology trigger – This is where it’s sparking interest and people are getting excited.
  2. The peak of inflated expectations – Early press emerges pushing towards the tech, but the technology’s capabilities are usually overhyped at this stage, and there’s the potential for disappointment. 
  3. The trough of disillusionment – Reality is now setting in, enthusiasm is waving and failures of the technologies are becoming apparent. (This is where we are at now.)
  4. The slope of enlightenment – Early adopters are now realising how to adapt the technologies, more technologies are being developed based on what users need.
  5. The plateau of productivity – Technology has now reached maturity and mainstream adoption is now beginning. The market is now seeing real-world benefits and increasing productivity but using the tools correctly.
An image showing Gartner’s Hype Cycle

We know based on Gartner’s Hype Cycle, and the current sales cycles for us poor marketeers, that companies are moving from the peak of inflated expectations to the trough of disillusionment. More and more platforms (think Google, LinkedIn, Instagram) are now penalising content that was being readily produced by AI models and now focussing on real-world examples. 

When it comes to generative AI, it has been used incorrectly. 

Relationship Marketing

Right, think of your first date with your significant other… You didn’t expect them to know everything about you did you? You built a relationship. You asked the questions. You delved into who they are and you explored what similarities and differences you have. 

Relationship marketing does just this. It is all about building those strong, long-term emotional bonds with customers to create loyalty and build trust, which in turn leads to repeat business or retained clients/referrals. 

The core aim is to keep your existing client base satisfied and engaged, recognising that loyal customers are your best brand advocates. And how can we do this? Through personalised and tailored messaging that AI just cannot do. It doesn’t know your customer base best, you do. Utilise that.

What AI is… and what it isn’t.

AI can, and I truly mean this, it can be great. It can be that really super-efficient intern, that copilot (hey Microsoft, well done to your branding team!) and that assistant you really should have. 

It’s great at:

  • Automating those repetitive tasks that drive you crazy
  • Analysing vast amounts of data for insights that go deeper than your knowledge
  • Improving decision-making by making predictions based on what it knows
  • HTML coding!!! It is a lifesaver and helping me fix broken code
  • And reducing human error across various industries.

But there’s a problem, especially if you think marketing can be fixed through AI. It will just produce generic, cookie-cutter marketing that sounds like EVERYONE ELSE. What does that mean for you? You’re just noise.

There’s an advantage to being human

You heard that right. There really is an advantage to being human. Although a robot that could clean would be nice…

Humans are naturally good storytellers. 30,000 years ago humans were telling stories. Maybe through cave drawings, but still the visual element was there. We were communicating. Storytelling is at the heart of being human. And that element of storytelling is what makes the best marketing, well the best.

AI cannot:

  • Share lived experience that makes people listen
  • Pick up subtle cultural signs when a campaign feels off 
  • And build relationships over months or years that turns into trust, loyalty and sales. 

That’s why marketers truly matter to businesses. We aren’t content machines. We’re good at content, don’t get me wrong, but we are interpreters, connectors and storytellers.

We’re seeing the turning point

We’re starting to see a shift. Companies that went all-in on AI are now quietly admitting that it didn’t deliver. Website hits have dropped (Google is now preferring credible and authoritative content over AI), Socials are stagnant (LinkedIn again prefers thought leadership) and brands are starting to dilute. Strong brands have lost who they are. And audiences are now spotting AI from a mile off. So they switch off. 

2024 was quite simply the year of testing the waters.

2025 is the year of course correcting. 

The agencies and freelancers, like us, who have weathered those pretty horrendous storms are now the guides and we’re helping companies blend AI with human creativity, instead of replacing it. 

AI isn’t going anywhere. And it really shouldn’t. When used correctly, it is such a powerful tool. But let’s be clear, it’s just that. A tool. It is not a strategy. The best marketing comes from the balance of AI for efficiency and humans for connection. 

I’ll leave you with my favourite reminder…

People don’t buy from algorithms. They buy from people.


Need a little guidance on where to go next? At Conv3rt Marketing, we’re all about partnering with you to provide the human touch. We offer free, no obligation calls to have a chat about where you’re at vs where you want to go, and how we can help you. Drop us a message to book yours.

Not in the right headspace for a marketing partner? Take a look at the Conv3rt shop to see what ‘off the shelf’ products could help get you on track. We’ve spent years honing our techniques, and now we’re sharing these as ‘ready-to-go’ packages that you simply take and apply to your brand. 

Posted in ,

Contact Us

Please enter your name.
Please enter a message.

Leave a Comment